Hi Simmo,
I hear ya'. I believe that would be a good thing. Clark passing over the captaincy and doing what he does best. Batting.
I have nothing against Clark's strategies. He is good at placing the field. His failing is he is not assertive. He does not have a confident air about him and therefore fails to instill confidence in his players.
Kym Hughes was of similar stuff. Border took the reins and the team became more aggressive in their playing style. Not winning at first but the seed was planted. Nurtured along by Taylor and blossoming under Waugh.
Those three captains played to win. "Get 'em, or get out."
A great team was handed to Ponting. The rot slowly set in. Ponting also a great batsman and captain strategist, but not aggressive.
Under the former captains Border, Taylor and Waugh; the Australians came under the media eye with their incessant sledging targeting the opposition. Under Ponting and Clark this reduced to almost non existent.
I am not suggesting that they should increase the abuse. It was an indicator of the confidence of the Aussie team at the time. It is not there now.
One of the most important constituents of a successful team is to have a captain who can conjure up confidence and motivate the team, while maintaining discipline on and off the field.
This is not an idle opinion that is uninformed or inexperience. I played a number of team sports and some I was either captain or vice captain. The players looked to me for assurance, for authorization and leadership.
I do want to reiterate at this point that I do not dislike Clark or Ponting. They are great players and as captains, great strategists. They simply lack in some necessary leadership skills.
There are better choices. Selecting captains on mainly their batting ability is not wise. Those of you who know of Douglas Jardine. He was not a great batsman. He was a leader. He was successful. However his methods were, "Its just not cricket" Which led to his demise.
Douglas Jardine is an illustration of my point. Its just that JD over did it and its the leadership that made that English team so successful that year.
Cheers