Redone Uluru star trails -preference please.

[batema (Mark)]

Hi,

I have batch processed my images and wonder your thoughts as to whether the first image (redone) is an improvement on the second (original posted) image.

Taken with a Canon 60Da using a Samyang 14mm f2.8.

Thanks,

Mark

[tilbrook@rbe.ne (Justin Tilbrook)]

Great improvement Mark!

Nice processing, worthy to hang on the wall.

Cheers,

Justin.

[strongmanmike (Michael)]

Because it contains nothing really interesting or relevant, I think the dark silhouetted foreground of the original works better

Mike

[Boyd]

Both great images Mark. If I had to choose it would be the original.
What exposure times or filters did you use?

Boyd

[RickS (Rick)]

The second image is technically better (IMHO) but the first wins on cool factor, Mark

[Carl]

Simple and effective

Cheers carl

[ourkind (Carlos)]

Hey Mark, I prefer the edited version. Would make a great background to use on composites when you're feeling creative