The Day The Earth Stool Still. To Be Aired.

[Zuts]

I usually get dissapointed by remakes of old scifi movies. Still I am always the optimist and was quite excited when war of the worlds was announced. That remake wasnt too bad. The worst remake I ever saw was the time machine.

Still, I had a look at the trailer and i reckon this movie could be bloody great, here's hoping anyway. I will definately be forking out some money for this one.

Cheers
Paul

[Ric]

As a sideline I was reading that "Starship Troopers 3" is out. Blimey I didn't even know there was a "2" out.

I'd have to rate the original as a classic "B" grade cult classic.

Cheers

[matt]

Haven't seen ST3, Ric...but 2 was a bit ordinary.

I enjoyed the first one though, and number three has been in video stores for quite a while now.

[Ric]

I'll have to have a visit to JB HiFi or someone like that and update my Sci Fi collection.

I'm getting a bit behind the times at the moment.

[jungle11 (Greg)]

Hi fellas - ST3 was absoulutely terrible - this from the biased sci-fi nut! Watch it at you peril hehe...

[Ric]

Thanks for the heads up Greg.

Cheers

[Dog Star (Phil)]

Ah, re-makes.
Let's be brutally honest here. They don't have a very good batting average, do they?
Two of my favourite remakes were Cronenberg's The Fly and Carpenter's The Thing. Both took the original idea, gave it a slightly different spin with a competent production crew and created examples of worthwhile cinema.
Then, on the other hand, we have The Time Machine, Planet of the Apes and I Am Legend, the latter of which is about to get the prequel treatment, can you believe? I can hear Richard Matheson's anguished screams of torment from here!
So, no. I'm not real optimistic of this currant re-make that we apparently had to have, but I'm going to see it anyway and hopefully, just maybe, it will fill me with wonder and awe, just like the original did.

[Kevnool (Kev)]

Originally Posted by interstellar

The Day The Earth Stool Still. For those who have not seen the original it will be aired Thursday night Dec 11th at 8PM. On AMC.

The AMC ? i dont know of that channel as were in oz Jeff but i did watch the original movie tonight ( and yes it is the first time ive seen it) and it must of been a blockbuster in its day and i really enjoyed it.
Now i cant wait to see the new version to compare the two.
So on that note i give it a thumbs up Cheers Kev.

[thorsdad]

The day the earth stood still is one of my favorites. I actually picked it up on dvd last year. An absolute classic film, without the cgi special effects of these days. I am looking forward to catching Keanu Reeves as Klattu, and have seen the extended preview on youtube. There will always be some differences as a twist to the old story. Fingers crossed.
I haven't seen I am legend yet, but I'm sure it's in the christmas stocking; The Omega Man was also one of my favorites. Will Smith and Reeves are a couple of my fav actors so hopefully they should be good.

ps. Who had that avatar of Gort, the Robot from Tdtess?

Cheers

[Dog Star (Phil)]

Originally Posted by thorsdad

The day the earth stood still is one of my favorites. I actually picked it up on dvd last year. An absolute classic film, without the cgi special effects of these days. I am looking forward to catching Keanu Reeves as Klattu, and have seen the extended preview on youtube. There will always be some differences as a twist to the old story. Fingers crossed.
I haven't seen I am legend yet, but I'm sure it's in the christmas stocking; The Omega Man was also one of my favorites. Will Smith and Reeves are a couple of my fav actors so hopefully they should be good.

ps. Who had that avatar of Gort, the Robot from Tdtess?

Cheers

I personally thought that I Am Legend was an abysmal film. I'd initially had high hopes for it too, given that they'd reverted to the original title of Matheson's great book.
Those who may think that I'm hung up on the book are probably right, although anyone who troubles to read the book may well see where I'm coming from.
The Omega Man wasn't, in my humble opinion, a very good adaption, but it was at least an enjoyable film.
An even earlier adaption was The Last Man, starring Vincent Price(!) as the lead character which was ..um.. different.
Having endured I Am Legend, you'd have to strap me into a cinema seat with a straitjacket and eyeclamps (a la Clockwork Orange) to get me to watch the forthcoming prequel.
"New" does not always equal "good", sadly.
Still and all, I'll be going to see the new DTESS. The original was such a strong story that it's difficult to see how they could stuff it up.
(But then I remember I Am Legend, and icey fingers of fear slither and contract around my palpitating heart.)

[toc (Tim)]

Come on guys, different stokes for different folks.

Personally I enjoyed both 'I am legend' and the modern remake of 'The Time machine'. Neither are great films, but I found them enjoyable. Then again I am a bit of a Will Smith and Guy Pierce Fan, (not to mention Samantha Mumba ) so that probably helps.

I have not read the original books they are based on. Its been a while since I saw the 1960's verison of the Time Machine, but I watched 'The Omega Man' recently, and actually much prefer 'I am legend'.

Im looking forward to the day the earth stood still remake, but I do understand the cynicism people have to remakes, since there have been some very average ones. Their usually not terrible, but they are sometimes very 'paint by numbers' efforts that dont show any real freshness or new orginality. (Im thinking of 'Flight of the Pheonix' here!)

[Dog Star (Phil)]

That's pretty fair Tim. As you say, different strokes for different folks.
I'm only too aware that the majority of people seem to have enjoyed I Am Legend, otherwise it wouldn't be getting the prequel treatment.
I know for a fact that various films I've enjoyed have been seen as turkeys by a majority of the viewing public. One example is Tank Girl, a film that I enjoyed immensely, but I appear to be a minority of one there.
There's no accounting for taste (yours or mine) and if I've denigrated something that you've enjoyed, then the fault is mine and I apologise without reserve.
I will say though that you wouldn't be doing yourself a disfavour by reading Matheson's I Am Legend or Wells' Time Machine, if only to see why various people went to the time, trouble and expense to try and adapt these great stories to the medium of film.
Cheers mate.

[DJDD]

Originally Posted by Dog Star

One example is Tank Girl, a film that I enjoyed immensely, but I appear to be a minority of one there.

or of two...
tank girl rocked...

[TrevorW]

Sci-fi is sci-fi leave your brains at the door there are rarely sci-fi films that do the term justice however if you are prepared to park your brain and enjoy them for what they are then you do. I've seen a lot of remakes and sequels

KK ( V i,ii,iii), Omega man (i am Legend), Planet of the Apes all of them, Time Machine,WOTW, The Thing, 2001, 2010, T1 2 3, The Blob, They Came to Earth, and as far as sci-fi goes some of the best never get remade eg: Forbidden Planet, Silent Running, 1984, and some shouldn't be like Black Hole, Saturn 5, Buckaroo banzai across the 8th dimension, Cone heads, Battlefield Earth.

but in saying that if you like sci-fi for what it is then you'll enjoy all of them regardless. So I'll be watching this one

[Omaroo (Chris Malikoff)]

Originally Posted by TrevorW

but in saying that if you like sci-fi for what it is then you'll enjoy all of them regardless. So I'll be watching this one

I heartily agree Trevor. I don't see that it is the mission of the film "re-maker" to satisfy anyones desire for a better, or at least "as good as" (whatever that is and however it can be qualified) film than the original. If you don't like re-makes then don't go and see them. Simple!

[Zuts]

This will be shown at the IMAX so i may go and see it there on the big screen

Cheers
Paul

[Kevnool (Kev)]

G----Genetically
O----Organised
R----Robotic
T----Technology

Cheers Kev.

[multiweb (Marc)]

Looking forward to this one. Should be an interesting remake. Love Sci-fi and try to go to the movies once a month. I go there to relax and dream, not to analyse.

[toc (Tim)]

Originally Posted by Dog Star

One example is Tank Girl, a film that I enjoyed immensely, but I appear to be a minority of one there.

Tank girl is cool little flick! Its been years since I watched it, so I will have have watch it again now

There's no accounting for taste (yours or mine) and if I've denigrated something that you've enjoyed, then the fault is mine and I apologise without reserve.

Hey, Im used to people bagging my taste (esp my wife!) so it would have to be in the order of 'Pink Floyd sucks!' to really piss me off

I will say though that you wouldn't be doing yourself a disfavour by reading Matheson's I Am Legend or Wells' Time Machine, if only to see why various people went to the time, trouble and expense to try and adapt these great stories to the medium of film.
Cheers mate.

I know, I know...For some reason I have an aversion to HG wells - I remember trying to read 'war of the worlds' when I was about 12 or 13 and was put off by the writing style. I was probably too young to appreciate it - but I had just finished off all of Tolkien's stuff, and it left me flat

[Kevnool (Kev)]

I can tell ya the new 1 its a gooden........cheers Kev.