Hi Mark;
Looks like a definitional issue surrounding what defines 'Bulge'.
There's been a lot of work done on this and clearly, the drivers/dynamics of what goes on at the core, at ~130 AU from a SMBH, is different to the mechanisms further out in the 'bulgy bit'. (See below for links for further reading).
Also, its interesting that Clarkson states:
Quote:
…. Such a bar-driven arrangement of the stars evolves over a timescale of several Gy, and can be transient with multiple generations of bar (e.g. Combes 2009). However, chemical evidence suggests the stars themselves mostly formed early and rapidly (e.g. Ballero et al. 2007; McWilliam et al. 2010). While the majority view now is that most stars in the Boxy/Peanut bulge of the Milky Way (which we call here “the bulge”) formed ∼10 Gy ago (e.g. Zoccali et al. 2003; Freeman 2008), the degree to which this star formation was extended over time, is presently only somewhat weakly constrained (Kuijken & Rich 2002; Zoccali et al. 2008). Thus, better estimates of the young stellar population of the bulge, and thus its evolution, are a natural dividend of constraints on the BSS {Blue Straggler Stars} fraction.
|
.. so anything they can deduce/discover would be better than almost nothing .. hence the 'excitement' they feel as a result of this work.
Here's a good paper, written by E. Athanassoula, which aims at classifying the structures of the 'bulge'. He wrote it "to avoid {the} considerable confusion" about the various interpretations of the term 'bulge', amongst his colleagues.
The same author, E. Athanassoula, also co-wrote a couple of other papers with M. Bureau in 2005 (mainly to do with
Bar-Driven Evolution & 2D Spectroscopy and
N-Body simulations of Disks, (if you're interested to do further reading).
Incidentally, all of the above references originally came from Clarkson's paper
here, (the one this article is about), and is worth the read, as it puts the whole announcement into better context, (than, perhaps, the journo articles in the media).
Hope this helps.
Cheers & Rgds.