The nebulosity is very good with a great range of hues and contrast.
However IMO the stars don't look natural.
There are many ways of doing it, and it's difficult to get right.
Wonderful result to catch this object so late in the season with such clarity and detail. A great example of what the 2600 is capable of doing in the right hands!
The big effort over many nights has paid off especially imaging M16 on the back end descending into the west
Splendid image, nicely processed
Well done !!
Martin
But... blacks are clipped and the detail within is lost.
A more subtle hand is needed.
Everything else is 1st class, well done!
Hi Andy,
It is a great image.
I don't agree that the blacks are clipped but they are far too low.
In Photoshop they were measuring only about 12 out of 256.
It would have been better to stretch the image in NASA FITS Liberator
before doing the processing.
( I think PixInsight will do that too? )
The stretch function called x^(1/5) would have given
a great compression factor to even out the large dynamic range.
Hey Greg, JA, Peter, Michael, Fred, Martin, Andy, Allan, Nik, Tony, Mathew, Marc, Adam, Ken!
Thanks to everyone for your comments & compliments!
Quote:
Originally Posted by Andy01
But... blacks are clipped and the detail within is lost.
A more subtle hand is needed.
Everything else is 1st class, well done!
Thanks Andy! My monitor is calibrated, but I usually finish processing at late night in a dark room, so I tending to make black level closer to zero. Close, but definitely not clipped, I'm keeping a close eye on it.
Anyway after reviewing it in the day, I partially agree with you that it looks too dark, so I made a bit a brighter revision and uploaded the update to Astrobin (https://www.astrobin.com/i1lmaq/C/)