Quote:
Originally Posted by Satchmo
Paul - these images are way over-sharpened - the artifacts in the rings are just ridiculous -multiple false shadow rings as a result of oversharpening . I don't understand why you are being so encouraged in present these images . I respect all the effort you go to - I don't respect rather uncritical nature of all the other posters - they are not exactly helping you to produce more realistic images in the future.
Just my 2c.
|
Mark, I fail to see the artifacts you elude to in your rather critical comments. After looking at the image for quite some time it seems to have a lovely 3D effect that I find quite catching. I understand from what you have posted in the past that you are quite an authority on optics but to make a critique on an image when I don't recall seeing any of yours and have to question if you have the skills or abilities to produce an image such as this let alone critique someone elses.
Paul, I find the image quite catching and a pleasure to look at and admire. I look forward to more like this.
Just my 2c worth.