Quote:
Originally Posted by DavidTrap
After reading some of your earlier comments, I don't think you can put your hand on your heart and make the first statement.
|
Hmmm... Anything I said in particular?
Quote:
|
As for the second statement, I find that the way you have processed the wavelets produces something that I don't believe actually exists. There is a distinctly rippled appearance to the nebulosity in your images which goes against what I expect a "diffuse gas cloud" to look like.
|
I can't (and won't) argue with belief, David.
Even in the face of overwhelming evidence to the contrary; the Carina nebula complex is far from a homogenously distributed cloud of diffuse gas. It is a very, very violent place with very active (feedback induced) star formation, gas displacement and concentration.
Quote:
|
Narrowband processing is extremely subjective. IMHO there aren't too many facts to apply here - a real blurring of the boundaries between science and art. I don't profess to be an expert, having only one tricolour NB image to my name LINK. Nonetheless, your processing doesn't do it for me. DT
|
Fair enough David.