View Single Post
  #88  
Old 06-02-2013, 11:44 PM
Satchmo's Avatar
Satchmo
Registered User

Satchmo is offline
 
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Sydney
Posts: 1,883
The sky in Canberra would be far better than Sydney Observatory. A 6" scope of any kind would show next to nothing but the Moon and Planets.


Quote:
Originally Posted by strongmanmike View Post
My experience is based on direct night after night side by side comparison from a light polluted commercial precinct in Canberra (The Trades Club) ie very similar to Observatory Hill (Not Wiruna) between a super high quality refractor with an equally super high quality and very expensive 16" F5 Newtonian. It is indeed very relevant to the discussion since we are talking here about potentially replacing a 16" scope, just as we had at the Canberra Observatory...aaand we essentially did replace the 16" and we replaced it with a 7" APO! simple As I said and based on extensive experience at a Public Observatory equipped with the some of the best scopes available including a C14 - for a public observatory in a heavily light polluted site a 7 -10" APO on a quality well known and therefore well supported mount, would be my 100% recommendation, without question and although sporting a smaller aperture and therefore dark sky abilities, to the lay person an equatorially mounted 8 or 10" refractor on a GEM will visually impress miiiiiiiles over a weird looking 20" Dob (that requires a ladder) ... and in spades!

Takahashi or Astrophyics mounts will be supported well into the foreseeable future I am sure.

Mike
Reply With Quote