Overall it looks pretty nice to me Paul
, the composition looks good and the colours are quite pleasing. As you would expect from me
, I think the smoothing is a bit too obvious
also, to me, the stars
look worked on and a little unnatural, I would like to see a version with the original stars. Processing the stars artificially to be smaller is always obvious to me, particularly if one uses the minimum filter in the sequence somewhere... otherwise, these minor mostly personal preferences aside...a really nice looking image
Mike