View Single Post
  #23  
Old 15-02-2006, 03:48 PM
PhotonCollector's Avatar
PhotonCollector (Paul)
All alone in the night

PhotonCollector is offline
 
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: Newcastle, NSW. Australia.
Posts: 607
Hi Robby and Itchy,

yeah I didn't want to say previously..... but since you have said it for me.

I certainly do and always have believed we have been "conditioned" over the past several decades (the film era) to expect to see nebula as red (or a hue thereof).

I don't really agree that all emission nebulae are just glowing in H-alpha (red) I think some glow in H-beta as well. H-beta is in the green part of the spectrum ! Don't get me wrong I'm sure lots of nebulae are just emitting Ha.

After Robbys posts on this thread I rechecked my images of the Tarantula to see if I could make it all red - but that would have meant removing all the photons collected in the green channel - which didnt make sense to me. I mean to say - if the camera collected strong photons in the green region of the spectrum then according to the data this nebula (2070) is glowing in green as well as red.

I guess this could be checked by seeing if the Tarantula is known to glow in Hb as well as Ha.

On this issue - you may note the amount of green I managed to get in a previous image of the Helix nebula at this location http://www.skylab.com.au/pmsa/Helix%20Nebula.html

I can say with certainty that the same camera on my 8-inch f/6 reflector basically did not reveal any green in the Helix (I'm using the 12-inch f/5 now) even with longer exposures.

Great talking to you guys

Paul Mayo
Reply With Quote