Quote:
Originally Posted by Archy
My you are all riled up. The original question started and ended thus
|
Being "smart" about it will not make your reply any less puerile.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Archy
Perhaps you are riled because the flaw in your postulate is that although you can measure the wavelength/frequency of the photon when it arrives, it is impossible to determine what the original wavelength/frequency of the photon was when it left the source, though you may speculate what it was.
Therefore you cannot determine the relative ages of photons X and Y
|
Let's make it clear right from the start....the relative ages of any photon have nothing to do with the question that
you specifically asked. Your question has nothing to do with the original question of Craig's.
Your responses show a clear lack of understanding either our answers or any of the physics involved. I doubt very much if you'd understand the original question that was posed.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Archy
Giving facile or abusive responses tends to cloud the issue.
Gentlemen, Goodnight
|
Don't try and sound all reasonable. It doesn't work. Yours is a case of the pot calling the kettle black.