View Single Post
  #15  
Old 13-09-2010, 02:37 PM
gregbradley's Avatar
gregbradley
Registered User

gregbradley is offline
 
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Sydney
Posts: 18,185
Try blackening the edges and chances are that will disappear. It was near Alnitak which is probably the worst reflection causing star in imaging. As to the physics of reflections - I think that can get pretty complex pretty fast.
Its not a comment on the brand of the filters as all filters have this issue. I am not aware of any of the filter manufacturers blackening the edges of their filters. It only takes a few minutes to paint the edges with a permanent marker. Just be careful, obviously not to get it on the main face of the filter but it does wipe off if you make a mistake, just do it fast before it dries.

I saw a similar reflection on a CDK17 image of mine recently. Only on a couple and it was also near a bright star and my edges were blackened but only with a permanent marker and perhaps a few areas weren't perfect. It was hard to see but it was there on a couple of subs. There was also some moon present.

Probably square are more prone to trouble as it forms a straight edge rather than scattering it everywhere with a circular filter. Easier to see the resulting reflection.

This blackening of edges is old data. I am surprised filter manufacturers don't do it. Eyepiece manufacturers have been doing it for ages. Televue eyepieces all have blackened edges of lenses.

Greg.
Reply With Quote