Oh and there was one other piece of evidence that this person should have picked up on to show his conclusion was invalid.... (I missed it the first time around). His lightcurve indicated that the eclipsing event made the object brighter. Now the only eclipsing events that I am aware of that can do this are microlensing events but to date I have not seen or heard of an asteroid moon with that level of gravity
. Looking at this last item I would find it very difficult to believe that anyone would actually publish it in a journal.