View Single Post
  #6  
Old 14-10-2009, 12:10 PM
renormalised's Avatar
renormalised (Carl)
No More Infinities

renormalised is offline
 
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: Townsville
Posts: 9,698
Smile

Quote:
Originally Posted by Robh View Post
Alex,

Interesting topic of discussion.
The sum total of all we see originated from a singularity after the Big Bang. Before the Bang, outside (whatever that means) of this singularity there was nothing- no matter, space, energy or time. This was truly a void.
Now, there are no voids. Any cubic volume of space at any time will have a measurable amount of mass or radiation (don't ask me how to measure it). Indeed, space itself may be related to energy in a similar way as mass is related to energy. After all, mass modifies space so it must be energetic.

Regards, Rob
To take that to a logical conclusion, even the thought of nothing, the existence of the concept, means there is something there. Therefore there is no void...in order for there to be such a condition there would even have to be an absence of nothing (as a conceptual entity).

Quote:
The sum total of all we see originated from a singularity after the Big Bang. Before the Bang, outside (whatever that means) of this singularity there was nothing- no matter, space, energy or time. This was truly a void.
This is true only from our present perspective. However, QM, Supersymmetry and String/M Theory would say otherwise. In these cases, the universe we see unfolded from a higher dimensional state, which whilst it may appear infinitesimally small from our perspective, is in fact many orders of magnitude larger than the universe we inhabit. Here space, energy and matter take on aspects which would be completely unfamiliar to us. Time itself would be something completely different, if it even exists at all.
Reply With Quote