Nah. Not bagging...just expressing a preference and an opinion of her in that particular role. Perhaps that's unpalatable to those like yourself who've expressed a liking for her...but that's the way it is. I'm sure she's very popular among those people who love her work, either in the series or as a comedienne.
It just appears a few of us do not fit into that category, but that's OK. Each to their own.
No-one has truly universal appeal.
I was assuming your original post was both a commendation for Catherine but also a call for discussion?
Anyway...long live the doctor!!!