View Single Post
  #1  
Old 15-10-2007, 01:58 PM
rodroger's Avatar
rodroger (Rodney)
Rod Burgess

rodroger is offline
 
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Redcliffe, QLD
Posts: 88
Collimating Newt short tube Advise

Hi,
Can any one advise me on a problem I have with the collimation of a 6"/f9 (150mmx1400mm) Newtonian.
It is a short tube and uses a corrector Lens (Glass) at the bottom of the focus tube to achieve the focal length.
I have tried to collimate this quite a few times now but still having problems.
I used a Celestron Cheshire/sight tube to allign the soundary, and a Saxon Laser as well, The only way I could align the main mirror was by removing the corrector lens (Jim Fly recommended to collimate without it in place). Every thing looks good but when tested on a star, I still do not get any leeway on the focus using a 25mm eyepiece. The image is either triangle in shape or ghosted - see two objects instead of one. (Mirror isd not pinched or not any more, as this was checked and fixed.) I noticed that if I rack the focus out the star colimation looks good but if I rack the focus in I get a elongated object. I removed the corrector and reversed the lens in the holder and tried again but still have the same problem but in reverse????
I also have noticed if I have it in focus (well what I think is in focus) I see a double of the image but if I avert my eyes sometimes or if I look down through bottom edge of the eyepice the image will come good. ?????

This is really sending me crazy, does any body have any suggestions besides getting rid of the telescope.????
Is the corrector lens flawed????

I can get this scope replaced by the maufacturer, as it is still under warranty, So far I have been under the assumtion that the initial problem when I recieved the telescope by courier was the optical train was out of alignment but if it is flawed then it has to go back.
I want to make sure before it goes back that it was not just the alignment or I will be charged a fee if not a warranty issue.
.
I have purchased one of Jim Fly's collimating Kits for a 1.25" and he has also put me on to a supplier of a Autocollimator for a 1.25" focuser which I will be buying at the end of the week
I am going to have so many collimating devices on hand soon that I will become an expert at it.

I just quckly tweeked my sons 6"/f5 and it is brilliant , even with a 2 x barlows and high mag lens (4mm) - amazing. .................Yet this scope is from the same maufacturer as mine (next model down - cheaper price too) except the focal length dose not use a corrector lens
Reply With Quote