View Single Post
  #7  
Old 02-03-2007, 04:27 PM
skies2clear
Registered User

skies2clear is offline
 
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Adelaide, South Australia
Posts: 238
Quote:
Originally Posted by leo View Post
There seems to be some doubt whether BVs work with Newtonians with a low focal ratio.
The William Optics website says "most" Newtonians are OK. Talks here are that possibly an extension tube or Barlow add-on is needed. But no one really seems to know.
Or any other brand?
Rather than buy and be disenchanted, does anyone have the experience to share?
Thanks

Leo
Leo and Larry,
From my own personal experience I can safely say the WO comment about working in most newts is very optimistic! Out of 4 I've tried, zero worked, with their supplied 1.6X OCS. I believe it does work with a short extension tube between the OCS and the BV, but the magX will increase further. I got it to work with a 2X barlow and no OCS, but this gives more like 4X. Most of these generic BV's will be the same.

In the end, I contacted Harry Seibert and ordered a Multimag OCS. This gives me 1.25X, 2X, 3.5X with newts and 1.25X, 2X, 3X and 3.5X with the refractor. Works in ALL my scopes now, including a 6" F8 refractor. The Seibert OCS is FAR superior to the WO one optically, btw. This WO/Seibert combo works very well for not that much money. The supplied WO 20mm eyepieces are reasonably good.

Clear skies.

Forgot to mention, the Seibert OCS also improves focus/sharpness at the edges of the field with all mag settings, and as far as I can tell with all eyepieces I've tried so far.

Last edited by skies2clear; 02-03-2007 at 04:30 PM. Reason: additional comment
Reply With Quote