Sorry to resurrect such an old thread. Only found out about this a couple of days ago. Sydney Observatory is off my list of organisations to support in any way. Which is a real pity as they do other positive things. But I cannot support them while they engage in this.
Since previous posts have cast doubt about the IAU's position, I think it's pretty clear from the below that they consider this practice to be "charlatanry". I don't believe the fine print makes it okay. By selling stars Sydney Observatory legitimizes all the private "registries" that also sell them and funnel the funds away from science, and they promote ignorance. I can't believe that an organisation with such a wonderful rich history has been reduced to this.
http://www.iau.org/public/themes/buying_star_names/
Quote:
"Q: The IAU pretends to be in charge of the sky - why don't you DO something about this??!
A: Sorry, much as we would like to, we are not under the illusion that the IAU can eradicate charlatanry: It has survived and thrived for countless centuries in many disguises - some far more dangerous than this particular example. All we can do is warn the public and try to prevent the abuse of our name and scientific reputation to mislead well-meaning customers.
Q: All this sounds negative and grouchy. I love the stars and a very special person and want to do something for him/her. What can I do ?
A: Lots! Go to your nearest planetarium or local amateur or professional observatory. They are staffed with people who feel just the same. They often have stores with books with wonderful astronomy pictures from the ground or from space, or fine astronomy magazines that all make great gifts. They can also direct you to the local astronomy club or society where enthusiasts will be happy to show you (and your friend!) the real stars through their own telescopes. Maybe you'll get infected and end up buying a telescope yourself?"
|