I am not a fan of others reprocessing your image for you. Its a bit like someone redoing your painting for you. You are the artist, you make the decisions good or bad. Technical points like too much noise, needs more exposure, stars aren't round are fine. But subjective points like colour and framing and methods of processing are a bit crossing the line in my opinion.
There are so many ways to processing an image that its not really granting the artist and their work any respect by redoing it for them. If you don't like the result that is the area where the audience can say - no, don't like it.
If the artist is a newbie and is after advice and help that's a different story. But that is not the case here.
Your original image is fine and needs nothing.
Greg.
|