I'm confused, Wavy. I've read lots of eyepiece reviews and don't remember an optical bench being a requirement. Aside from that, the review addresses all your points.
Three scopes are mentioned thoughout the review, as are three comparison eyepieces: a Pentax XW, Tak LE and Tak Abbe.
All the aberrations mentioned are essentially absent or on par with the other eyepieces.
There was no blackout issue.
Eye relief not measured but nothing to suggest it isn't the claimed amount.
Seems fairly complete and thorough to me?
