hi Mike
Good to see people holding photographers up to a high standard. There are plenty of doctored reflections around but this one looks about as I expect, although pushed heavily to bring out the reflection.
As Marc says, in a reflection the stars are bloated a little so bright stars gain in brightness relative to the Milky Way. If the Milky Way is the dominant feature then I get suspicious.
Here are two examples of mine for comparison:
Pano and
Portrait
Phil