Which of these 3 boabs?

[iceman]

Just after some feedback, which of these 3 photos of the boab appeal to you most?

I've been looking at them too long and can't decide.

Thanks!

[Larryp]

The close-up. This, IMHO, focuses my attention on the tree, and not the background, and also brings the moon more to the fore.:thumbsup:

[GeoffW1]

Yeah, No 3, the closest. Has everything.

Cheers

[Rodstar]

I prefer the colour palate of the first one. Orange and blue - complementary opposites on the colour wheel. The moon is better placed in a richer coloured sky.

[leon]

No 2 Mike the dryer looking background makes it look real Australian.

Leon

[Allan_L]

Hard to pick a winner.
I like number 3,
But I think number 1 is my pick.

[Davros]

number three for me

[pluto]

Number 1 Mike.

[Astro_Bot]

It's a close call, as they all have something to offer. So, IMHO ...

The first is best framed and most symmetrical, and second-best colour rendition.

The second has the best colour rendition.

The third has the best position of the moon in shot, and the green adds a nice contrast.

I'd pick the first one if I had to.

[ourkind]

No 1. It captures the full tree no branches missing. Like the darker shade too.

[Joshua Bunn]

No. One Mike, better framing IMO.

[iceman]

Thanks guys, some mixed opinions but looks like #1 is on top so far,

[Deeno]

Boab behind door number 1 thanks!

Think its the only one thats perpendicular.....

[Chris.B]

I'd go #1 as well, the colours make it stand out.

[iceman]

I've gone #1.

Large version here:
http://www.mikesalway.com.au/download/319

Thanks for the feedback.

[stardust steve]

after a close race between 1 and 3. I think #1 won by a head in a photo finish.:)