Saturn - DMK and DBK side by side

[Frewi808]

I feel like Darryl now, did the same processing on both images taken with the DMK and DBK, it's up to you guys who wings here.
Again RGB filter capturing and processing is recently new to me, but I can see who wins, DBK color has much less processing involved, but when seeing is king.....
Let me know what you guys think.
Freddy

[Troy]

Hi Freddy,
Both images are fantastic. IMO the DBK image is slightly in front, the image is smoother and the C ring is well presented. But for this type of thing you should have matched the image size more closely.

Well Done

[bird]

Hi Freddy, something's happened to the DMK image to make the edges look serrated, not as smooth as the DBK image. Did you rotate it or something?

cheers, Bird

[Frewi808]

Hi Anthony,
I used Winjupos, that's all, but I still have to learn a lot about RGB processing, I'm more used to the color processing.
Indeed the processing is not so smooth as the DBK, I will look into that, have been trying for weeks now to get my processing finally working, but still have a lot to learn.
It might be also due to the fact that I 'squeezed' them to get them both in the frame..
Freddy

[Frewi808]

Tried to pull out more of the two images, The DMK is indeed sharper but does not
show the crepe ring like in the DBK (??)
Maybe have to work on the capturing & processing settings more. Lot to learn in
so little time left..
I also post the individual images..hope they are the same size and orientation
now.

Again, this is not a scientific experiment, but I guess the DMK mono give a more
crisp result. It's very hard to process them both the same, the DMK has a much
more complex and time consuming processing then the DBK color camera. But the
result is much better in MHO.
Just let me know what you think or where I went wrong..
Suggestions welcome...(or PM me)

[Shiraz]

both very good Freddy, but I prefer the DBK result. regards Ray