View Full Version here: : A bit of everything ... NGC 6559, IC 1274 and IC 4685
marc4darkskies
21-08-2009, 05:53 PM
This image has a bit of everything - dark, emission and reflection nebs and it's embedded within the rich star fields of Sagittarius - a riot of colour!
It's an LLsRGB image 7 hours total. I was initially going gather Ha for this as well but didn't bother as my effective 4 hours of Lum (2.5hrs Lum filter + 1.5hrs Synthetic Lum (Ls = desaturated RGB) revealed enough of it. Also my Ls had tighter stellar profiles than my L (1.5 vs 2.2 pixels FWHM) so combining the two kept my stars tight. Seeing on the 2 nights I imaged was around 2-3 arsecs (I won't mention the completely wasted night where the guide star frequently exploded into a 10 arcsec fuzz ball! :mad2:).
I shot this at the native FL of the Tak (F7.3, 1.67 arcsec/pixel) - nice wide, unvignetted flat field (using the 67 flattener). In any case I ended up cropping slightly for composition purposes because in the full frame the subject was off center ... and we can't have that!!
Enough waffle - here 'tis ...
Small:
http://www.pbase.com/gailmarc/image/116319109/large
Large (4MB - use <ctrl-> to zoom out & <ctrl+> to zoom in)
http://www.pbase.com/gailmarc/image/116319109/original
Hope you like it.
Cheers, Marcus
DavidU
21-08-2009, 05:57 PM
Nice work there Marcus ! 7hrs on the Tak just works. The #67 seems to do the job
Excellent
Bassnut
21-08-2009, 06:04 PM
Very smick Marcus, lots of sharp detail fishing around in the big version, and nice colour too.
Wonderful, absolutely wonderful Marcus !
Gorgeous colours, stars nice and tight, what more can I say.
The full frame almost gave me vertigo. :lol:
A beautiful frame indeed.
The TOA 150 with 67 flattener......mmmmmmmm !
:)
multiweb
21-08-2009, 06:20 PM
:jawdrop: That is superb Marcus. The colours and resolution are unreal. What a shot! :eyepop: :thumbsup::thumbsup::thumbsup: By Ls do you mean you stacked the masters RGB into another Lum in addition of the Lum data you shot?
Lumen Miner
21-08-2009, 06:42 PM
That's just UNREAL!!! :prey2:
Lester
21-08-2009, 06:45 PM
Thanks Marcus, that is a beautiful image.
renormalised
21-08-2009, 06:50 PM
Only one word....gorgeous!!!!:D:D
Another work of scientific art....great shot Marcus:D:D
Peter Ward
21-08-2009, 06:54 PM
Think you are on a roll now...do ya?...punk?
Damm...very tidy indeed. :)
marc4darkskies
21-08-2009, 10:42 PM
Thanks a lot David! The 67 is a sweet piece of glass for sure ... should be too - it wasn't cheap! :scared:
Thanks Fred. Interestingly I didn't apply any sharpen filters to this image except for some "real" unsharp masking to enhance contrast.
Hey thanks Andrew & fellow TOA'er! Yep, I think I need to do more imaging at F7.3 - stars are pinpoints edge to edge!
Cheers Marc. I use Ls by layering in a desaturated version of the combined RGB image in PS. The method really depends on what you want to achieve but in this case, as well as improving S/N, I wanted to rein in the stellar profiles so I did a darken layer at 67% after making sure the nebulosity was normalised with the raw lum.
Thanks Mitchell glad you liked it! :)
Cheers, Lester!
Thanks Carl - if there's one thing I've learned, processing is indeed 80% art and 20% science!
Thankyou master, I am most unworthy of your praise ;):D.
I guess if the clouds are not rolling in as often as usual then, yes, I'm on a roll. ;) (DANG!!! Shouldn't have said that should I - they probably heard me! :doh:)
Look forward to your first STX shot!
Cheers, Marcus
gregbradley
22-08-2009, 12:47 PM
Another great image Marcus.
Potential winner for next year?
Did you bin the RGB 2x2? I often see lower FWHM numbers for binned RGB compared to
Luminance images at 1x1. So is that when you want to use the desaturated RGB for extra lum to get the
tighter FWHM of the 2x2 RGB? I tried desaturated RGB as extra L but didn't see much of a gain. As you say I suppose it depends on what you are trying to accomplish. I guess if the L is a bit noisy still it would be helpful or for galaxy shots where you you want max data.
Greg.
Paul Haese
22-08-2009, 01:18 PM
Nice Marcus, love the colour and the field of view. Lovely work.
Matty P
22-08-2009, 08:56 PM
Just stunning Marcus. I'm still picking my jaw up off the floor. :)
:thumbsup:
marc4darkskies
22-08-2009, 10:25 PM
Thanks Greg - I'm pleased with how it turned out and was glad to be able to avoid the hassle of another Ha combine. With I think one exception I always image unbinned. In fact you shouldn't do synthetic lum if you've binned your RGB - you'll sacrifice resolution. The FWHM differential is mainly the result of seeing in this case. I suppose there would be some contribution from the difference between the effective passband of the combined RGB vs the Lum - but probably small. I guess I should quote FWHM in arcsecs to avoid confusion too.
Cheers Paul - gad you liked it. Even though I cropped for composition I didn't snip too much off - just some of those pesky stars! :D I wanted to highlight how the loop of dark neb frames the subject.
Thanks Matty - it's such a vibrant, colourful field with so many facets it'd be hard NOT to make it look good! It's often overlooked though because of it's famous neighbours - I only discovered it recently myself :shrug:
Cheers, Marcus
Martin Pugh
23-08-2009, 01:00 PM
Hello Marcus
very nice indeed, but it does not compare to your Corona Australis image which I think is just exceptional in every way.
I also enjoyed a good look around your website tonight, and your running photo-commentary of your observatory construction was very good.
Well done mate
cheers
Martin
Alchemy
23-08-2009, 05:33 PM
very nice, good color, smooth, nice contrast....
where did the guy in the big hat go? someones pretending to be you !
gregbradley
23-08-2009, 05:49 PM
Thanks for the tip Marcus.
Do you think there is always a gain from 1x1 on the RGB?
Certainly your image in this case is fantastic but do you always see a gain from it or is better to simply do more luminance at 1X1?
I suppose there are 2 schools to this but if one advantage is the ability to add desaturated RGB to the luminance that is something of a dual purpose to your RGB.
I guess in my case recently with such a continual run of poor weather the question is moot anyway.
Greg.
marc4darkskies
23-08-2009, 08:40 PM
Hey thanks Martin - appreciate that!! Yeah, it didn't take me long to figure out how much I hated set up & tear down - I had the observatory built after only 5 or 6 sessions I think. So how's the cloud cover in Nebraska?
Cheers Clive! Hmmm yes, the hat was almost a signature thing wasn't it? ;) Maybe I'll grow it back!! :shrug:
You'll only get a gain (from Ls) when the RGB is the same or better resolution than the Lum - in which case you always get a noticeable improvement in S/N and the processing benefits that brings. I consider it a bonus when I can do it. I dunno, it's probably just a personal preference thing whether you spend time gathering extra lum or more time gathering RGB in 1x1 :shrug:. But, I DO like the idea of using the RGB data twice!! ... It feels like you're getting something for nothing :)
Cheers, Marcus
Peter Ward
23-08-2009, 11:20 PM
SBIG say no STX until next month and no matching CFW until October :(
..and will probably run with 3" diameter threads so nothing I have will actually fit. Arrrrgh! What have I done!
I predict clear skies between now and then.....but an unsually wet summer.
marc4darkskies
24-08-2009, 05:19 PM
Bugger ... commiserations! I'd have thought they'd try and make the upgrade path a bit more straightforward. :shrug: What about an AO-L - bet you need a new one of those too ... the AO-X??!! I think I'll stick to my trusty STL for a few more years - I hate thinking about adaptor bits and back metal distances anyway.
Cheers Marcus
PS: Thanks in advance for the clear skies - they must be above the rain clouds here at the moment.
Octane
24-08-2009, 06:48 PM
Marcus,
Nothing much needs to be said, other than that is utterly superb.
It's like something out of a dream or a landscape painting of the celestial kind.
7 Internets to you, sir.
Regards,
Humayun
marc4darkskies
24-08-2009, 08:44 PM
Thanks a lot Humayun! I'm really glad you see the image that way - that's pretty much the effect I like to achieve!
Cheers, Marcus
strongmanmike
25-08-2009, 01:17 AM
Yeh, I think this is your best and nicest image to date mate :clap:, really colourful and very nice to look at.
Needs a bright star in the bottom left corner though :whistle:
Mike
h0ughy
25-08-2009, 07:32 AM
awesome - so much eye candy.
gregbradley
25-08-2009, 08:33 AM
I agree Mike. I also think it is an outstanding image. The subtle colours are fantastic and the detail you've captured is hitting way above your aperture. The TOA150 is one of the greats.
You know on the Anacortes website they say Tak has a 110mm and a 180mm TOA planned. Probably not during the global financial crisis but a 180 TOA could be nice eh? It'd be heavy but nice.
Greg.
marc4darkskies
25-08-2009, 09:49 AM
:lol: Aaahh, sorry about that oversight Mike. If it's any consolation I was thinking of you when I kept the yellow pimple at the bottom of the frame :P
Thanks a lot mate! :)
Cheers David - not quite one of Mike's "heavenly bodies" but the next best thing for sure! :)
Holy cow - a TOA 180??!! Just thinking about it gives me a hernia ... and my bank manager would have me committed ... and my wife would divorce me ............... and ..... it'd be worth it :D! Seriously, I think we'll be waiting a loooooong time before we see one.
Thanks Greg.
Cheers, Marcus
atalas
25-08-2009, 12:26 PM
Wonderful Marcus!
vBulletin® v3.8.7, Copyright ©2000-2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.