PDA

View Full Version here: : Book review - The First Astronomers: How Indigenous Elders read the stars (2022)


Pierre_C
25-01-2025, 03:15 PM
The First Astronomers: How Indigenous Elders read the stars – book review

Duane Hamacher has written this masterful book about how indigenous peoples have viewed, interpreted and used the stars and celestial sights as part of their daily lives. His insights are based on critical research and guidance from indigenous elders and knowledge holders.

He shows how concepts such as the passage of the stars and constellations across the night sky, their changing characteristics, the phases and angles of the moon, the wandering planets, the position of the sun and even the dark depths of the Milky Way have informed the daily life of indigenous peoples past and present.

He reminds us that if scientific method is the repeated observation of phenomena to generate theories which are tested with more observations, then the indigenous peoples were accomplished scientists. They tested and refined their theories over tens of thousands of years, connecting the facts of nature with understandings relevant to human experience and to living life on Earth.

I found this book pleasing to read, like being taken on a nature journey by patient and knowledgeable indigenous guides. It gave me a deeper appreciation of how what I see in the night sky with my eyes really connects with the fundamental ebb and flow of the essence of living life.

There is something deeper on offer here – the ‘rediscovery’ of a meaningful and tangible connection to the night sky that has been lost to modern scientific method.

‘The First Astronomers’ is published by Allen & Unwin, 2022. All royalties go to charities supporting First Nations projects and people in astronomy.

I have written this as an independent review.

Further information can be found at https://www.thefirstastronomers.com

Matthieu
25-01-2025, 10:15 PM
Thanks for the review.

I’m about a third of the way through the book and very much enjoying it so far. It makes me wonder what other knowledge was lost from ancient cultures across the world.

Rainmaker
23-02-2025, 08:40 PM
Likewise !

gnair
03-03-2025, 10:09 AM
Thanks - Egyptians did the same thing and is well documented in a book called Orion's Myster by Bauval. Will definitely read this one.

Peter Ward
07-03-2025, 09:17 PM
I posted some thoughts on that book here on ISS years ago...and sorry...absolutely not a fan.

I think it's the biggest piece of a-priori rubbish I have read in quite some time.

There is nothing masterful about this book except perhaps the politically correct BS that masks "stories" and a sheer lack of scientific method as viable science.

P.S. I think Les Dalrymple (rest his soul) summed up this tripe up best when he wrote this on IIS.....
"
The findings in the book generally lack scientific rigour. One example: As Peter noted there is nothing in any aboriginal oral tradition or sky legend in relation to the supernovae of 185AD, 1006, 1054, and 1604 that all would have been very prominent sky events in the southern hemisphere. There are however oral traditions in relation to the eruption of Eta Carinae about 180 years ago which is a very recent event in context arguing powerfully for the unreliability of oral traditions past a few generations as a primary source of actual history. They are so very easy to artificially re-construct if the narrative demands it.

"A Priori " -- very much so."