PDA

View Full Version here: : Flattener advice please


pmrid
11-06-2024, 09:08 PM
I've made a cute 80mm F5 shortie achromat out of bits and pieces I have cobbled together. It's probably going to be used for a bit of lunar on the go but even so I would also like to flatten out the field a bit so I can have the option to use NB filters (so CA is less of a problem) for a bit of deep-sky imaging as well but those streaky stars are a real PITA that I'd like to eliminate.

But I don't want to bust the bank on this either.

Does anyone have any suggestions for a cheap generic flattener? I already have a Hotech Field Flattener but I just can't get the spacing right so I'm looking for alternatives.

Camelopardalis
12-06-2024, 07:56 PM
Bottom if a coke bottle? :D

By.Jove
17-06-2024, 12:51 PM
A simple weak plano-convex doublet placed in front of the focal plane will flatten the field of a simple achromat or triplet refractor. If you nominate the focal length of your objective, the desired focal length of the flattener can be calculated, it doesn't have to be exact either, +/- 20% would be fine.

And it also acts as a modest reducer.

NB this is the reason why the simple doublet "reducers" work so well with small refractors and cassegrains.

AlexN
02-07-2024, 04:25 PM
Back in the day I used a Baader newtonian coma corrector to flatten the field on my TMB 80/480... Started at the MPCC's recommended spacing, then slowly moved inwards until I found a point where it was plenty flat enough for the KAF8300 chip I was using...

A cheap coma corrector could certainly do the job of flattening the field for you Pete..