Log in

View Full Version here: : Horsehead Nonsense and Sense


N1
21-01-2015, 03:28 PM
This may have been posted before, but...

What a refreshing read!!! :thumbsup:

http://freescruz.com/~4cygni/haggisizing/astro/HH-sense.htm

Crux
21-01-2015, 05:09 PM
Thanks for posting.

Hayden

ralph1
21-01-2015, 07:52 PM
Very interesting, and I agree with what it said. Personally I was able to see it in a 130mm reflector but only on a very good night.

N1
22-01-2015, 07:25 AM
I found this after a little search I did after repeatedly reading comments on various fora suggesting that it's bigger than you think versus you must have at least [enter huge value here] inches of aperture. From the article it appears the only must-haves for IC434 if not the horse itself are a dark sky with excellent transparency and a certain exit pupil size. And maybe an appropriate filter. Magnification, and therefore aperture, seems to get 4th priority at best :question:. Can't wait to put that to the test...

geolindon
22-01-2015, 05:48 PM
interesting and technical thread. i have dark skies on the coastal range in a high rain fall area.

i tried several times with my stock standard 8" sky watcher and TMB 100 9 mm / 25 mm cheap plossl. with out seeing the broader area of nebulousness. causing me to double check i was looking in the right place. also i was unaware of it's (apparent) degree of difficulty.

the very first time i tried with the GSO 16" and same ep, there it was, faint and translucent/transparent but easily seen AND right where it should be :) clouds interfered with attempts to id the actual horsie, a Y2C to look foward to.
Lindon

geolindon
22-01-2015, 06:32 PM
interesting and technical thread. i have dark skies on the coastal range in a high rain fall area.

i tried several times with my stock standard 8" sky watcher and TMB 100 9 mm / 25 mm cheap plossl. with out seeing the broader area of nebulousness. causing me to double check i was looking in the right place. also i was unaware of it's (apparent) degree of difficulty.

the very first time i tried with the GSO 16" and same ep, there it was, faint and translucent/transparent but easily seen AND right where it should be :) clouds interfered with attempts to id the actual horsie, a Y2C to look foward to.
Lindon