PDA

View Full Version here: : July Obs Challenge - The DARK side


mental4astro
03-07-2013, 12:38 AM
Good evening, my fellow "nocturnians",

It has been a very long time since The Challenge was issued. With Scorpio high overhead at this time of the year, I thought it appropriate to delve into the occult side of astronomy - dark nebulae.

These darkest of features of the sky tend to reveal themselves only when one is at a dark site. Their very nature sees them recoil out of view at the mere hint of light pollution, almost skulking way from the light. But their true nature is very diverse - some the cloaking cocoon of proto stars that await the ignition of their nuclear fire, others the remnant gas and dust left over from stellar formation that lingers in the interstellar space like the smoke of an extinguished match.

With the blaze of the Milky Way's hub overhead, these rarely chased features come into a league of their own by obscuring the background glow of our home galaxy. Now is the time to chase these shadows in the sky.

Naked eye

From a dark site, these dark features can be easily seen tracing lines through the band of the Milky Way. They form some very interesting features that resemble terrestrial creatures, such as the "Dark Horse of Sagittarius" (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:GreatDarkHorse_Nebulae.jpg), and the "Emu in the Sky" (http://aboriginalastronomy.blogspot.com.au/2011/04/coal-sack-and-emu-in-er-i-mean-llama-in.html) from Aboriginal sky lore. The Southern Cross harbours the famous "Coalsack Nebula" (http://www.farnham-as.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/2.-SouthernCross-Pointers-Eta-Carinae-Nebula-text.jpg) that actually forms the head of the "Emu".

Binoculars

The inky blackness of the Coalsack is very striking from a dark site. This cloud of molecular gas and dust that never got formed into a star or planet just lingers within the Milky Way, waiting for the chance to be formed into something more than just gas and dust. Panning a pair of binos east from the Southern Cross, the background glow of the Milky Way abruptly stops on entering the Coalsack. And a beautiful juxtaposition of light and dark is had when the Jewel Box is gained into the field of view - It really is a gorgeous sight the brilliance of the Jewel Box with the "rude" blackness of the Coalsack.

The brilliant globular cluster Omega Centauri is surrounded by soft, tenuous fingers of dark nebulosity. These details are rarely noticed for the brilliance of Omega. Binoculars offer the best chance to view these details of variations in the illumination of the background glow.

M7, the giant open cluster at the base of the stinger of Scorpio also is home to some fabulous dark nebulosity, really only noticed with the rich field of binoculars. The cluster is criss-crossed with soft lines of dark, and a fantastic dark ribbon licks the edge of M7 (called B283). This is one of my favourite compositions made by these two DSO's.

Eta Carina, the magnificent emission nebula, is marked by the dark lines that form its lobes. Binoculars here show how expansive this nebula is, and how delineated it is by dark material. It is a fabulous vista this expanse, with so much mottling of the whole field. I'll review Eta a little more in the Telescope section below too.

One last thing with binos and a dark site - slowly scan the heavens, regardless of the time of year. Big binos, 70mm and up, will show a staggering amount of detail in the sky, even in areas that seem devoid of much influence of the Milky Way. Big binos will show the softest of variations in the background sky glow that telescopes will just miss altogether. It is these quietly spoken details that can be so charming.

Telescopes

Here we hunt down the occult demons. Serpent like structures can be teased out in bright nebulae. Splashes of pure black, almost like angles have lifted a tiny veil in the sky to allow us to peer into the beyond. And the tell-tale signs of massive stellar activity as massive shockwave fronts are formed. Here the powers of the occult prevail...

Eta Carina. The super massive star that lends its name to this nebula is in its death throes, experiencing spasmodic eruptions as its spent hydrogen fuel struggles to maintain its balance between equilibrium and cataclysmic collapse. These eruptions have created a shock wave that's rushing out from this star. The wonderful dark structure that is "The Keyhole" (http://imgsrc.hubblesite.org/hu/gallery/db/tours/tour-carina/tour.swf) forms the foreground limb of this shock wave. The dark nebulosity that forms the Keyhole is full of fine soft details. Ironically, right next to the soon-to-happen supernova is an area rich in stellar formation. The sharp edge of the Eta Carina nebula show fantastic dark pillars. The surrounding "light" area of the glowing gas and dust is being open up by the energy of the newly formed star cluster Trumpler 14. Yet the tell tale signs of stellar formation is seen in the dark fingers that form the dark pillars. Here, the gravitational pull of proto stars holds the surrounding gas and dust that is otherwise being blown away by the nearby star cluster. These dark pillars will eventually too be blown away when the nuclear fire of these proto stars kicks in.

"The Ink Spot Nebula" (http://www.waa.at/bericht/2010/07/20100709-11hwp/20100710api2-12-n6520.jpg), aka B86, is a stunning raven black nebula. Immediately next to a brilliant, compact open cluster, NGC 6520, the contrast between light and dark is just stunning. The all pervasive brilliance of this area of the Milky Way just stops with a BANG! It sits on the edge of the densest star cloud in the entire sky, and is truly stunning. Sneaking its way between M7 and M8, it inconspicuously goes about its occult business. Just beautiful.

My last offering is a mix of several distinct objects in the one field of view that can be a little challenging. These objects are on the boundary of Corona Australis and Sagittarius. Dark nebula Be 157 is surrounded by the soft glow of a two distinct reflection nebula (NGC6826/7, NGC 6729 & IC 4812) and the lovely globular cluster NGC 6823. This grouping is a lovely spectacle in just about any scope. Different eyepieces are recommended to be used as this will give a variation in contrast, magnification, and field of view, all combining to enhance different aspects. This amazing image of this area (http://www.martinpughastrophotography.id.a u/images/NGC6726-25pct_Labelled.jpg) was taken by fellow IISer Martin Pugh. It shows the incredible expanse and detail that is area.


I hope this Challenge provides some new targets to chase for you, or a new view on them. Dark nebulae tend to be forgotten, and pushed away from our thoughts due to the colourful brilliance of their loud cousins. But they can provide a lot of insight into the forces that create and change this vast galaxy that is our home. I hope you can add some more dark objects to this listing too.

Mental.

Steffen
03-07-2013, 01:30 AM
Join the Dark Side – get a free cookie :)

The thing with dark objects is, they require dark skies to be enjoyed. That's why I'm looking forward to next Saturday at the airfield. From home I can barely make out the coal sack most nights.

Another interesting dark object to add to your list is the Doodad in Musca. Supposedly a 3˚ long bino target I have never actually seen it myself.

Cheers
Steffen.

mental4astro
03-07-2013, 10:12 AM
Bugger, I always miss out...

One more binocular target to add. An amazing collection of light and dark surrounds the grouping of M8, M20 and M21. Not only are these impressive on their own, but as a collective through binos, and amazingly extensive amount of dark nebulosity also fills the area. Gossamer-like curtains screen out areas of background star clouds, while dark, sinister fingers punch their way through the scene.

As Steffen also affirmed, a dark site is necessary to see these dark features. However, the dark nebulosity and dark pillars in Eta Carina can be easily seen from urban areas. An OIII filter is a help to tone down the light pollution sky glow. The dark pillars could be more challenging, but I have spotted them in an 8" scope from my home in Sydney without filters. If you don't have an OIII filter, try using different eyepieces to vary the contrast in the image produced.

ZeroID
03-07-2013, 01:02 PM
Dark Site ? What's a Dark Site ? At present all I've got is a 'Cloud Site'. Must be under construction or something .....

Thanks for the list all the same, lovely descriptive prose as well. They might be refractor visible if we get a good cold southerly in to clear the air.

glend
03-07-2013, 01:32 PM
I was lookinv at the grouping of M8, M20, and M21 last night and it certainly a crowded area with lots of attractions. I see it was writtn up in the Bintel newspaper as well.

Paddy
03-07-2013, 10:22 PM
Great idea to include dark nebulae Alex!

madbadgalaxyman
07-07-2013, 07:56 AM
My favourite dark nebula for the purpose of assessing sky conditions is the particular edge of the Coalsack which is seen when sweeping from the direction of the Jewel Box cluster(NGC 4755)

It is precisely because the contrast between the obscured side and the unobscured side is not so great, that the level of sky transparency and sky darkness has such a great influence on what exactly you see in this part of the Coalsack.

In poor sky conditions, it is just possible to detect the influence of the dust on the obscured side......but all you see is a falloff in star density.

In reasonable dark sky conditions, it is possible to get some idea that there is actually obscuring material on the obscured side.

It usually takes excellent dark sky conditions for the obscured side to look really inky, in contrast to the unobscured side.

The Dark vs. Bright side contrast of a familiar dark nebula is a superb non-numerical test of how good the sky is.

Here is the section of the Coalsack I am talking about
(the cluster at top right is NGC 4755). Because the starry background is not super-bright and the obscuration is not high, you know you have an excellent sky when you can see this well in visual observations.

143099


P.S.
As we discovered years ago when viewing through Mark Suchting's 8 inch binoculars, dark nebula observation really comes into its own with a binocular telescope. Some of us got so inspired by this that we sometimes spent most of the night viewing dark nebulae.

Contrast is a critical factor on these challenging dark objects; very good light transmission and very good baffling in your telescope are therefore important if you want to see dark nebulae at their best.

For my money, a good pair of apochromatic 5 inch binos would be the best instrument for dark nebulae and for general sweeping of the Milky Way.

mental4astro
26-07-2013, 08:06 AM
In looking for a bit more information on visual observation of dark nebulae, I've come across a great list for this very purpose:

Best of Barnard's Dark Nebulae (http://www.saguaroastro.org/content/Best-of-Barnards-Dark-Nebulae.htm)

A very helpful note on the list is the grading of the 'darkness', which is on a scale of 1 to 6, with 6 being the darkest against its parent background.

RobF has posted a stunning image of the dark nebula B84, "the Claw" (http://www.iceinspace.com.au/forum/showthread.php?t=109571), in Sagittarius. This one is rated as a 5, so should be a very nice one to chase down. Within the same field of view also lies a globular cluster and a planetary nebula. If the PN is difficult to spot from amongst the background stars, "blinking" it with an OIII filter will help here. If you are unfamiliar with "blinking", have a look in the "honing your observing skill" sticky, where I posted a very easy to make 'blinking paddle' for this purpose.

Mental.