Go Back   IceInSpace > General Astronomy > Astronomy and Amateur Science

Reply
 
Thread Tools Rate Thread
  #1  
Old 21-03-2016, 08:56 AM
madbadgalaxyman's Avatar
madbadgalaxyman (Robert)
Registered User

madbadgalaxyman is offline
 
Join Date: Mar 2011
Location: Brisbane
Posts: 936
Review: Stellar Evolution books (easy Undergrad to early Graduate)(advanced Am.Astron

Stellar Evolution books - take the next step upwards after elementary "popularizations"

After you have read one or more Very Easy "descriptive" books on Stellar Evolution at the 'popular science' level, how best to take the next step towards gaining a very detailed knowledge and physical understanding of stellar evolution?

One onward path towards achieving expertise is to read some books that give much greater detail on the subject, with expositions that include real physical and mathematical argument.

To facilitate this pathway, here is a list of relatively easy (but rigorous) "introductory-to-intermediate level" books on Stellar Evolution & Stellar Structure, with the readership level of the individual books somewhere within the range of "lower undergraduate" through to "easy graduate texts". In other words, in these books you can expect to find graphs and algebra (but not millions of equations from cover to cover!) plus a modest amount of calculus, though with the maths and physics leavened with substantial amounts of descriptive material.

These books are readily understandable by the average amateur astronomer only if she/he has already studied a good year of rigorous maths and physics at the tertiary level. Advanced-level amateur astronomers will take to them quite easily if they have enough mathematics to be confident about:
- algebra
- the graphical display of functions and relations between variables
- some elementary calculus and differential equations; an introductory university calculus course is a desirable prerequisite for some of the harder material in these books.

Many of these books also contain substantial sections that are moderately accessible to people with a good Australian secondary school Maths and Physics, preferably also having a really excellent background in advanced amateur astronomy. But those sections on the physics of stellar interiors are more likely to require a minimum of a good 1st Year University (or advanced college) physics and maths.


These belowlisted books are in my own personal library, and I use them to pursue an "on again and off again" course of study in the theory of stellar evolution.
_________________________________


-"Stars and Stellar Evolution", by K.S. de Boer and W. Seggewiss, 2008, ISBN 9782759803569
An excellent concise primer on stellar evolution. All the observational facts are here, but without bogging the reader down in the recondite physics of stellar interiors. This terse volume somewhat resembles an excellent set of university lecture notes, but it is also greatly padded out with ALL of the necessary details. It is not too maths heavy , and contains megatons of useful stellar data and HR diagrams! The good thing about this book is that it presents the intricate and non-simplified details of how various types of stars evolve, but mainly in terms of the Observables and their functional relations.....for instance: surface temperature, stellar mass, stellar luminosity, Color-magnitude diagrams, SEDs and spectra. The necessary equations are there, but the pages of this book are not loaded with complex physics and mathematics. Mind you, if you are only used to descriptive books on astronomy, it is still very far from being an easy read.


- "Life and Death of the Stars", 2014, by Ganesan Srinavasan, Springer-Verlag, ISBN 9783642453847 .
I really like this book.....as I can easily understand the physics and maths in it (My mathematics is OK, but I am no mathematician as my maths is still stuck at the mid-undergraduate university level). This is one of the easiest-to-read undergraduate-level courses in stellar evolution, and it is very understandable, as the physics and maths is pared down to the necessary minimum. Srinavasan says that he only assumes that you understand physics at about first-year university level, e.g. that you have understood the likes of "Halliday and Resnick".
However, the author's somewhat simplified approach to the necessary physics and mathematics does not sacrifice scholarly rigour and sophistication; in this respect, Srinavasan's book is markedly superior to a lot of the other introductory (early undergraduate) astrophysics books, which are too often oversimplified to the extent that the simple level of the exposition hinders the future progress of the student's understanding.


- "Unsolved Problems in Stellar Evolution", 2000, edited by M.Livio, Cambridge University Press, ISBN 0521780918 .
An excellent course in the basics of stellar evolution, without any over-simplification. Quite a lot of the text is descriptive, but the text is complex and physical in orientation, and it is fundamentally very highbrow and "technical" in content.
It mainly uses graphs rather than equations to display numerical relations, so this makes it relatively accessible, even for super-advanced amateur astronomers and for undergraduates in the physical sciences.
See madbadgalaxyman's review of this book at (American) amazon.com


- "Introduction to the Theory of Stellar Structure and Evolution", 2010/2011, 2nd edn, by Dina Prialnik, Cambridge University Press, ISBN 9780521866040 .
This book is a well-regarded textbook on the physical theory of stellar interiors, here reduced to its basics.....but even the basic physics of stellar interiors is still hard (unless you are very conversant with physics!).


- "Evolution of Stars and Stellar Populations", 2005 , by Salaris and Cassisi, John Wiley & Sons, ISBN: 9780470092200
An essential reference for the intermediate-to-advanced student of stellar astronomy, describing the modern approach to stellar evolution. The sophisticated exposition in this book stands in marked contrast to the often out-of-date and/or oversimplified material found in many lower-undergraduate astronomy textbooks. At least Seventy percent of this book sticks to observables such as Color-Magnitude diagrams, graphs of scaling relations, and spectra. While this book is usually regarded as a "graduate level" or "beginning professional astronomer" text, this work is so clear and observationally-oriented that the resolute physics/maths undergraduate or the Super-Advanced Amateur Astronomer can (at least with some struggle!) understand large sections of it.
See madbadgalaxyman's review of this book at (American) amazon.com.


- "Stellar Spectral Classification", 2009, by Richard O. Gray and Christopher J. Corbally, Princeton Series in Astrophysics, Princeton University Press, ISBN 9780691125114
This book is literally "The Bible" of stellar spectra and stellar spectral classification. This massive and comprehensive and scholarly work is an essential reference for all optical and near-infrared astronomers. This book explains the current iteration of the standard MK System of Classification of the spectra of stars, and it contains a comprehensive collection of stellar spectra , with detailed explanatory information on the many stellar types, including spectra and explanations of most of the recently-discovered stellar and sub-stellar types (e.g. the L & T dwarf classes, and brown dwarfs). Extreme and rare stars like O2/O3 stars and Wolf-Rayets and LBVs get a much greater coverage than in earlier references, reflecting today's greater knowledge of these "superstars". This work somewhat resembles a supercharged and super-extended version of Kaler's popular-level book on Stellar Spectra.....and it is much more up-to-date! Because the Spectral Classification of Stars does not have to involve lots of hairy physics and mathematics, this is an area of professional astronomy in which amateur astronomers can become highly competent.


- "An Introduction to Modern Stellar Astrophysics" by Dale A. Ostlie and Bradley W. Carroll

I have this book, but I have only read 30 percent of it, so I am unsure as yet if I can recommend it. This tentative review records my initial impressions of this work.

This is a "basic to early-intermediate level" quantitative/numerical/physical textbook on stellar structure and evolution, at the undergraduate level. In other words, it assumes an absolute minimum of a good Australian Year 12 advanced maths & physics, though in reality a good First Year University maths and physics would be better preparation for the reader. Mercifully, there is also significant descriptive material to leaven the equations.

At face value, this is a typical "American textbook -style" introduction to the basics of stellar astrophysics, and it is suitable for people with a physics/maths orientation; in other words, suitable for those people who are comfortable with equations and graphs and who have done at least an introductory calculus course (with a few differential equations). The authors write: "Our goal in writing this book was to open the field of modern astrophysics to the reader by using only the basic tools of physics". Those sections that I have read engage in the maximum amount of 'handholding' for the reader, and the authors explain astrophysics in a style and simplicity which makes it (hopefully) accessible to the numerate "everyman" who has at least some physics and maths.
The mathematics and physics and the arguments are indeed simplified and reduced to their absolute essentials.....which has the significant drawback that if the reader wants to go further and eventually to become a senior-undergraduate to graduate Level astrophysicist, he/she will have to restudy these topics in much greater breadth and detail. Therefore, I warn here that astronomy textbooks that are explicitly designed for beginning undergraduates, often tend to oversimplify matters in order "to ease your passage into" astrophysics , thereby hindering the future progress of the reader's understanding. In summary, Ostlie and Carroll are bravely attempting to "gently ease the reader into" the inevitably difficult field of astrophysics!
_____________________
_____________________
______________________

Last edited by madbadgalaxyman; 27-03-2016 at 08:20 AM. Reason: change of title
Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old 31-03-2016, 08:28 AM
Weltevreden SA's Avatar
Weltevreden SA (Dana)
Dana in SA

Weltevreden SA is offline
 
Join Date: Apr 2012
Location: Nieu Bethesda, Karoo, South Africa
Posts: 216
I second Robert's list as a good way to get into stellar evolution & its physical tracers. I tote along the K.S. de Boer and W. Seggewiss and the Salaris and Cassisi books with me on every dark site visit. They are pretty well thumbed by now as quickie fact-finders whenever I need to refresh on some property or other. For some reason Dina Pralnik's book doesn't measure up in this league.

There is a freebie alternative to the Grey & Corbally "Stellar Spectral Classification" book available here. Scroll down to "Download English Documents" & have a good read from his half-dozen self-produced books. These aren't dilletante productions by any means. There's a surprise in store on p.207 of his "Spectroscopic Atlas for Amateur Astronomers". A number of the high-res spectra he analyses were acquired with his own Celestron C8 kitted out with one very comely focal plane spectrometer. The massive compilation of internet links starting on p.208 of that same monograph is a freebie cornucopia of anything you could ever want in the field of astronomical spectroscopy. He even has one spectrum of a lightning bolt!

Thanks for starting this post, Robert. I hope you follow up with other recommendations in the many specialties that interest us.

=Dana in S Africa
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 31-03-2016, 10:19 AM
madbadgalaxyman's Avatar
madbadgalaxyman (Robert)
Registered User

madbadgalaxyman is offline
 
Join Date: Mar 2011
Location: Brisbane
Posts: 936
Quote:
Originally Posted by Weltevreden SA View Post
For some reason Dina Pralnik's book doesn't measure up in this league.
I am glad you agree with my recommendations of De Boer & Seggewiss, and Salaris and Cassisi. Though we aren't exactly typical amateurs......."super-advanced amateur astronomers" is arguably a better descriptor than "advanced amateurs", as we quite commonly sweat through papers in the AJ, ApJ, etc.
(The average amateur astronomer will find these two books much too hard! )

Prialnik is essentially a well-written book about the astrophysics of stellar interiors, so it is well suited to its purpose, but it has much less emphasis on the observables of how stars evolve, in the practical sense of the time-evolution of the observable (or easily derivable) stellar quantities with time (e.g. luminosity , colour, mass, spectrum, radius, etc.) . Prialnik emphasizes the physics of stellar structure, supposedly reduced to its 'basics'......but even reduced to its basics, this stuff is hard!....unless of course the reader is a physicist or has a degree in applied mathematics. Prialnik requires, as an absolute minimum prerequisite, that the reader has had a good dose of undergraduate physics and mathematics.
Essentially, Prialnik is an astrophysics textbook, and if you have ever tried to sweat through any kind of astrophysics text, you will know that astrophysics textbooks are mainly suitable for people with a very strong maths and physics orientation.

Prialnik is commonly regarded as one of the most accessible of the "physics and maths intensive" texts on stars.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Weltevreden SA View Post
Thanks for starting this post, Robert. I hope you follow up with other recommendations in the many specialties that interest us.
As you know, I personally own most of the textbooks on galaxies, and stellar evolution, and the interstellar medium, as long as the readership-level of the book is not above that of some of the easier upper-undergraduate and graduate texts.

However, I dip into astronomy and galaxies much less frequently than I used to, as I have been working my way through my vast and comprehensive collection of books on the Australian landscape, geology, biology, and ecology. So madbadgalaxyman is essentially in recess, a lot of the time.

Two of the "free" books that I gave links to in my email to your gmail address are absolutely the most Dana-relevant texts that I have seen for a long time:

"Lessons from the Local Group", eds Freeman & Elmegreen & Block, published by Springer
Cost is $349 (!!!!) US Dollars, so hard to feel sympathy for the publisher if people find ways to get it for much much less.
This book is a very worthy successor to Sidney van den Bergh's year 2000 book that summarized all that was known about the LG at that time. It would seem that 20 times as much is known about the LG as was known in year 2000!

"Accretion Processes in Star Formation" by Lee Hartmann.
Wonderfully accessible Cambridge Press book on star formation, at the upper-undergraduate level, and not too hard for the likes of you and me. But how amazing that 7 years after publication, the book is now already substantially out-of-date!
___________________

Oh, and on the topic of "super-advanced amateurs", one of our spectroscopists has just been a co-author of a peer-reviewed scientific paper. He goes by the name of Bernard (IIS userid = Glenpiper)
___________________

Last edited by madbadgalaxyman; 31-03-2016 at 10:44 AM.
Reply With Quote
Reply

Bookmarks

Thread Tools
Rate This Thread
Rate This Thread:

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT +10. The time is now 11:13 AM.

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.8.7 | Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Advertisement
Bintel
Advertisement
Testar
Advertisement