Quote:
Originally Posted by Redshift
Do you think dark matter is seriously possible or is it still in the realm of science fiction?
|
The wonderful thing about dark matter is that as it is not nailed down all are entitled to a view.
My view is that it is a myth.
It is necessary to support the misconception that a force of attraction is real...and it is obviously not a reality..attraction is a myth that is in the minds of humans who can not comptemplate the altermnative because of the current views it destroys. Mind you GR I believe mentions no force neither attraction or push.
Attraction is a force we place so much faith in and yet it is really not there...it is not a reality..there is no such thing...nothing more than a myth related to human experience..which is totally unreliable.
Now that is unacceptable for most folk but when you think it thru there is no basis for the force of attraction...It has never been scientifically established..never never never never...and no one can provce or establish it is a reality...nothing establishes attraction...I know we all see attraction but all you see is push analysed as attraction...Attraction was a given before science got there... now without attraction we must face a reality that everything works basically from a radiation pressure... think of what pressure there is in a void... maybe... but E=MC^2 suggests to me that if we convert all energy passing by any point anywhere in the universe to mass (simply for an understnading of the force that may be at play) we get a view of "outter space" as most complicated and jam packed with something... now all this passing stuff may be the dark matter but they see it different to me... they see dark matter as static and I see it as moving at or near C....They say dark matter is clustered... I say it is to fit the demands of attraction to make everything work... Whereas I see a flow (at c in every direction) rather than clumps of stuff undetectable other than to employ our sums of attraction to say it is there ...Dark matter exists because the attraction sums demand its presnce..push sums do not need it at all.... A universal flow of stuff I would suggest will take dark matter out of the equation... Why elect for a universe with magic and mystery that attraction demands when an enviroment of push or a universal flow of matter or energy provides possibly a pressure that makes everything work so very simply.
Science builds on the works of what others have done before and that is wonderful ..however when the concept of an aether was removed we entered an unrealistic view of the universe... If we are to accpet dark matter we must revive the aether one would think...
I am into the belief that all things work by push ..not attraction..push works in my simple mind models but as imaginative as I am I can not see "attraction" as a force that is a reality...
I believe there is no such thing and so I dont need dark matter in my universe.
The razor tells us simple is good complex is bad and to go simple it probably is correct... well I go with that..and attraction is so complicated to outline I dissmissed it as being fanciful...the implication of attraction is that every object in the universe is in personal contact with every other object...I find that impossible and impractical..yet all our science insists attraction is a force.. and so we must have dark matter... dark matter..mmm lets think about it... we can see it..it has no radiation.. does that add up..why would the universe put such stuff in... I find it easier to accept Newtons statement that the force of gravity is the force of God than I can accept that we have stuff that has no radiation and is only apparent by implication from gravitaional expectations... and dark matter..is to make up 90 % of our universe but we can not see it etc... try push and it is not needed ...
The fact is if you work out the sums as far as dark matter you find you can never never never add or subtract enought to do the job... all calculations are based on local observations yet if you extend the problem you will find addition of more and more nmatter makes things worse not better... and I have done sums in spite of my non relience on math for most of my conclusions on observations I have made....
I was into math once... but that is the only time you will hear that.
Still I am me and me is of no importance and have no recognition so why could I be right... Like Dr A or any of them being the first to see something is not good as others will say you are nuts...but I was not first to see this... DrA's supporters seek a monopoly on thinking it seems.
I dont care really ..there is no cash in this so it is always a hobby...time will prove me correct maybe so I am not concerned... not concerned if I am wrong either..it is after all an idea...unsupported..but I did nail the Pioneer thing so I am one up (in my view) as they say. If only Newtonian was used they could never conclude what I concluded... GR would have been a worse result actually...do the sums if you doubt me.
So these are the ramblings of a crazy person enjoy them as entertainment and you wont go wrong.
alex
