View Single Post
  #1  
Old 02-07-2017, 10:55 AM
Atmos's Avatar
Atmos (Colin)
Ultimate Noob

Atmos is offline
 
Join Date: Aug 2011
Location: Melbourne
Posts: 6,984
UV/IR filters and Astrophotography

I've had my Sigma 85mm out under the stars twice so far, the first time without a high quality UV/IR filter and the second with one. I usually have a high quality UV/IR filter living over the front of my lens' as a protection against the elements. A hardy piece of glass that is worth $100-150 but makes sure that nothing damages the real nice glass that comes with your high quality lens Bit of rain, dust, splashes of mud; remove lens, clean and put back on. No harm done.

After the 4+ hour ordeal of calibrating, debayering, registering and stacking my Rho Oph shots, most of which taken on the second night, I couldn't help but notice that the stacked image lacked the sharpness of the first night and displayed some weird star shapes.

This morning I went and stacked 8x120s from both the first night (no filter) and second night (with filter) and have since come to the conclusion that for astro work, NEVER using a filter.

I did attempt to get these two comparisons down to <200kb but by that point the quality was too bad to even tell the difference between them.

First Night (without filter)
Second Night (with filter)

Both of these are shot @ F/2.8 with a Nikon D7200 (APS-C with 3.91 micron pixels and no anti-aliasing filter)

I think for every day usage the filter is worth while, the sharpness difference is possibly not perceivable when shooting anything other than stars. Still, it is something to think about.
Reply With Quote