View Single Post
  #2  
Old 11-08-2013, 08:33 AM
gregbradley's Avatar
gregbradley
Registered User

gregbradley is offline
 
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Sydney
Posts: 17,901
Cool project. I was thinking of monoing a DSLR. An old 5D would make a great mono DSLR. They are cheap, they have large pixels (deep pixel wells) and probably easy to pull apart to get to the sensor and they are full frame.

I have Nikon 85mm F1.8 and have imaged with it. It needed around F2.8 to clean up the coma so its not just the chromatic aberration (CA) that needs to clean up its the coma. But F2.8 it should be fine as I recall.

As far as which HA filter to get that is not so clear. I think typically DSLR users go for a wider Ha filter than dedicated CCD users do. That lets in more wider band light to get a decent exposure. But then only 1 pixel out of 4 registers the Ha and even then it has to make it through a red filter as well on top of the already abysmally low QE of a typical DSLR sensor. But monoed hmm, QE is probably back up there with many CCDs.

The latest DSLRs have improved QE. The best QE is the Toshiba 24mp sensor in the Nikon D7100 at over 60%. The Nikon D800E is next best with its Sony Exmor 36.3mp chip and I think the D600 with its Sony Exmor 24mp chip.

But the older 5D is probably pretty good as it has quite large pixels for a DSLR so that gives it deeper wells which is also good for astro imaging.

So does your camera it into the poor QE, red filtered weak Ha signal so needs a wide Ha filter or the CCD every pixel counts with high Ha performance (QE)? Probably more the later so that would lead me to expect a medium width Ha filter of around 7nm. Baader makes a 2 inch circular 7nm Ha that is "fairly cheap". 3nm besides being extremely expensive are unlikely to be suited as they really require a fast scope (not too fast though) and high QE sensor.

That may be the go.

I'd love to see the results and get an idea of the sensitivity of the stripped sensor. It could be a cheap way of getting a mono full frame sensor that is currently around $6-10,000 all up cost in astro CCDs.

Greg.
Reply With Quote