View Single Post
  #1  
Old 24-08-2018, 09:08 AM
Imme (Jon)
Registered User

Imme is offline
 
Join Date: Aug 2017
Location: Kyneton
Posts: 840
ZWO ASI120 Colour v Mono mini sensitivity comparison

I'm making the move to an OAG from a ZWO guidescope.
The guidescope has worked flawlessly for me......I'm changing purely to try and improve my pictures as I'm told this is what I need to do (yet to be proven but I'll give it a try!)

I have been using an asi120 colour (USB3) with the guidescope but probably require something a little more sensitive for the OAG so I started looking at a mono camera. The obvious (cheapest) choice was to go down the track of the asi120 mono mini.

You know what though......NOWEHERE on the web could I find actual evidence of how much more sensitive a mono camera was compared to a colour one. Best I could find is numerous posts on what people thought, but no actual evidence. Ridiculous hey!

So here is the evidence.......all pics taken of the same patch of sky within a 5 minute period under 98% moon. PHD2 screen contrast slider was all the way to the right (darkest)
  • Pic 1 ASI120 Colour (USB3) through a ZWO guidescope (Gain 95, Exp - 3 sec)
  • Pic 2 ASI120 Colour through a ZWO guidescope (Gain 95, Exp - 3 sec). Binning 2x2
  • Pic 3 ASI120 Mono mini (USB2) through a ZWO guidescope (Gain 95, Exp - 3 sec)
  • Pic 4 ASI120 Mono mini (USB2) through a ZWO guidescope (Gain 95, Exp - 1.5 sec). Binning 2x2. Note this was a 1.5 second pic as background sky brightness due to the moon gave me a white screen.
I'm feeling confident the extra sensitivity of the mono, especially when binned, will work for the OAG.

Telescope is a WO FLT132 F7, OAG will be the ZWO model (yet to arrive).....anyone comment on their experience with this camera/OAG setup?
Attached Thumbnails
Click for full-size image (IMG_20180823_213352 (1024x768).jpg)
180.0 KB101 views
Click for full-size image (IMG_20180823_213418 (1024x768).jpg)
192.4 KB105 views
Click for full-size image (IMG_20180823_214017 (1024x768).jpg)
198.0 KB102 views
Click for full-size image (IMG_20180823_214153 (1024x768).jpg)
40.8 KB110 views
Reply With Quote