Scoper
22-07-2006, 11:05 AM
Finally got a 10" dob from Andrews: sent on monday and I received it wednesday; great service!
Very impressed. The scope arrived almost fully collimated, just slight adjustment of the secondary mirror was needed. Having once owned a 6" f/4 telescope I am well versed in collimating fast newtonians.
The secondary holder was spot -on centred in the tube and the primary was fully adjusted, you can check the primary collimation two ways: 1 by using a sighting "eyepiece" in the focusser and 2 by tilting the scope and looking down the tube at the secondary and its image in the primary; with one eye you then match the secondary just within the outline of its image; any slight misalignment of the primary shows up like the proverbial dog's wedding tackle.
The offset in the secondary was almost spot-on, Just minor adjustment needed here (I also have two methods I use to check this).
As for first light, well it was cloudy wednesday night (of course) but thursday I was able to check the optics using magnification of 166x and 270x. No sign of spherical abberation (must allow mirror time to cooldown for this check as mild undercorrection occurs during cooling); no zonal errors that I could see, essentially the same diffraction pattern either side of focus and no astigmatism noticeable including pinched optics. The claim of 1/12 wave accuracy must be pretty close.
Jupiter was a real treat. Also indulged myself in an orgy of gazing at some well known DSO's: Sombrero, ngc 5128, ngc5139, Sag/Scorpiuos region etc. Wonderful!
Got 4 eyepieces with the scope: 4mm,9mm,20mm and 25mm Plossls. All but the 4mm are reasonable, the 4mm is actually quite useless. Already have a 15mm gso superview and an old 20mm erfle. All the eyepieces (barring the 4mm which will remain redundunt) work fairly well at f/5 but a vast improvement is noticed at the edge of field by using them with a 2x Barlow. I suppose this is why some high cost eyepieces work so well, they employ a built-in Barlow. I must comment that the 15mm superview does give a ghost image so better for dso's than planetary.
Am impressed with the price and performance of this scope--optical quality at a reasonable price has certainly improved. Very pleased and congrats to Andrews for good service and products.
One problem is the dob base being a little too stiff despite the central bolt not being tight, may need extra teflon pads close to the bolt.
Another concern I did have was the size of the secondary mirror--at about 60mm it is 1/4 the size of the primary! However judging by the views of Jupiter this should not be a problem---I've come to believe that the supposed "destructive effects" of the central obstruction in reflectors is grossly exagerated( but Have yet to test the 10" against my 8"f7.4 which has a secondary mirror 1/6th that of the primary diameter).
Am I happy? You bet! GSO are the best thing for amateur astronomy.
Thanks to those Iceinspacers who convinced me.:thumbsup:
Cheers Malcolm.
Very impressed. The scope arrived almost fully collimated, just slight adjustment of the secondary mirror was needed. Having once owned a 6" f/4 telescope I am well versed in collimating fast newtonians.
The secondary holder was spot -on centred in the tube and the primary was fully adjusted, you can check the primary collimation two ways: 1 by using a sighting "eyepiece" in the focusser and 2 by tilting the scope and looking down the tube at the secondary and its image in the primary; with one eye you then match the secondary just within the outline of its image; any slight misalignment of the primary shows up like the proverbial dog's wedding tackle.
The offset in the secondary was almost spot-on, Just minor adjustment needed here (I also have two methods I use to check this).
As for first light, well it was cloudy wednesday night (of course) but thursday I was able to check the optics using magnification of 166x and 270x. No sign of spherical abberation (must allow mirror time to cooldown for this check as mild undercorrection occurs during cooling); no zonal errors that I could see, essentially the same diffraction pattern either side of focus and no astigmatism noticeable including pinched optics. The claim of 1/12 wave accuracy must be pretty close.
Jupiter was a real treat. Also indulged myself in an orgy of gazing at some well known DSO's: Sombrero, ngc 5128, ngc5139, Sag/Scorpiuos region etc. Wonderful!
Got 4 eyepieces with the scope: 4mm,9mm,20mm and 25mm Plossls. All but the 4mm are reasonable, the 4mm is actually quite useless. Already have a 15mm gso superview and an old 20mm erfle. All the eyepieces (barring the 4mm which will remain redundunt) work fairly well at f/5 but a vast improvement is noticed at the edge of field by using them with a 2x Barlow. I suppose this is why some high cost eyepieces work so well, they employ a built-in Barlow. I must comment that the 15mm superview does give a ghost image so better for dso's than planetary.
Am impressed with the price and performance of this scope--optical quality at a reasonable price has certainly improved. Very pleased and congrats to Andrews for good service and products.
One problem is the dob base being a little too stiff despite the central bolt not being tight, may need extra teflon pads close to the bolt.
Another concern I did have was the size of the secondary mirror--at about 60mm it is 1/4 the size of the primary! However judging by the views of Jupiter this should not be a problem---I've come to believe that the supposed "destructive effects" of the central obstruction in reflectors is grossly exagerated( but Have yet to test the 10" against my 8"f7.4 which has a secondary mirror 1/6th that of the primary diameter).
Am I happy? You bet! GSO are the best thing for amateur astronomy.
Thanks to those Iceinspacers who convinced me.:thumbsup:
Cheers Malcolm.